Showing posts with label Race. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Race. Show all posts

Saturday, September 19, 2009

Racism in America Doesn't Stop with Glenn Beck and His Fans -- It's in Our Health Care Debate Too

Share


FROM: AlterNet
By Allison Kilkenny, True/Slant. Posted September 18, 2009.
As much as white Americans hate to admit it, race issues are always in play, whether we're talking about unequal health care access or Limbaugh's latest rant.

President Obama has long suggested that he would like to move beyond race. The question now is whether the country will let him.

He woke up on Wednesday to a rapidly intensifying debate about how his race factors into the broader discussion of civility in politics, a question prompted in part by former President Jimmy Carter's assertion Tuesday that racism was behind a Republican lawmaker's outburst against Mr. Obama last week as the president addressed a joint session of Congress. -- via Political Memo – As Race Debate Grows, Obama Steers Clear of It – NYTimes.com.


There is a prevalent misconception that racism is a self-contained problem. The myth goes like this: unless a hooded clansman is burning a cross on an African American family's lawn, the United States is not dealing with traditional racism. Our country has transcended race, since the election of President Obama, this myth says. Furthermore, race is only a relevant factor when something overtly hostile happens to our leader, who happens to be black (not that any of us notice, since we have transcended the problem of racism). The myth leaves no room for discussions of institutionalized racism, or the acceptance that race and racism are always in the room with us, and not just when President Obama delivers nuanced, thoughtful speeches about them.

Aside from the obvious targets of a Joe Wilson or Rush Limbaugh, the problem of racism infests every facet of the American experience, including the ongoing health care debate, though few politicians and journalists seem to realize racism is bigger than a few of Glenn Beck's disciples shouting something about Obama being Kenyan. "Race issue lingers over health care debate," an AP headline declares, but what it fails to mention is that the health care debate is also a race debate, and the racism issue does not belong exclusively to the province of zaftig, paranoid white Conservatives, flawed reasoning that comforts many liberals.

Another Reuters headline reads, "Healthcare, anger, and race," presenting the three nouns as if they are separate, autonomous entities. Such compartmentalization seems to suggest we can only talk about one issue (healthcare, anger, or race) at a time. We're either chatting about Obama's plans for health care reform, or we're snickering about those crazy birthers, but we're never talking about the same thing. However, in reality, the broken healthcare system and anger are subsidiaries of racism, and the three share a deeply interconnected relationship.

According to a study by researchers at Dartmouth, race and place of residence have a huge impact on the kind of medical treatment a patient receives. For example, blacks with diabetes or vascular disease are nearly five times more likely than whites to have a leg amputated. The widest racial gaps in mammogram rates within a state were in California and Illinois with a difference of 12 percentage points between the white rate and the black rate. The country's lowest rate for blacks — 48 percent in California — was 24 percentage points below the highest rate — 72 percent in Massachusetts. In all but two states, black diabetics were less likely than whites to receive annual hemoglobin testing. But blacks in Colorado (66 percent) were far less likely to be screened than those in Massachusetts (88 percent).

Next page (2) »

Powered by FeedBurner

Friday, July 17, 2009

Pat Buchanan is right. This white man is full of resentment.

Amen docterry, you nailed it.


FROM: THE DAILY KOS
by docterry [Subscribe]Thu Jul 16, 2009 at 07:21:51 PM PDT

I am a white man, an old white man, a rich old white man, by any reasonable measure; and Pat Buchanan is right. I am full of resentment. Let me tell you what I resent.

I resent a jackass like Pat Buchanan busting a vein about how white working men suffer when an 'undeserving' poor woman like Sonia Sotomayor gets ahead in the world by virtue of her own ability and her own skills.

I resent Buchanan saying she didn't deserve her admission, her grades, her awards, her editorship, her success as a lawyer, as a judge. If I could reach through the Internet tubes I would smack him silly.

More of my resentments below the fold.

I resent watching my father work three jobs to feed our family, watching my mother sew mens suits for 30 years, and then watching rich-kid punks like George W. Bush have life handed to them because of their daddy's name and their granddaddy's money.

I resent the Henry Ford VIII's of the world getting their first paying job as an executive vice-president when mine was cleaning toilets and my father's was landing poor white soldiers and marines on a fire-stormed beach at Okinawa.

I resent that black men and women were firehosed, beaten, killed by men like Jefferson Beauregard Sessions III because they dared demand the most basic human rights and justice.

I resent rich white men complaining because the merest handful of the poor; white, black, red, yellow or brown; are given a chance to show what they can do after decades of being spit on by the Pat Buchanans of the world.

I resent Pat Buchanan pretending to defend the white working man when for all his life he has done nothing but defend the privilege of the rich against me, my family, my brothers and sisters of all races, creeds, and cultures who were denied a seat at the table reserved for the bluebloods, regardless of their ability.

I am a proud product of a public kindergarten, public elementary school, public junior high school, public high school, two land-grant universities, a government graduate fellowship and a decade's work treating the seriously mentally ill for the government. I spent half of my life on the educational dole, and I resent seeing rich kids with half my brains and a tenth my work ethic waltzing into Ivy League schools because they have the right name and the right private school background. I resent that Buchanan has no problem with THEM taking seats from deserving poor white men.

I resent seeing my wife's family business, 75 years old and into its third generation, threatened by a herd of Wall Street bankers who wrecked the economy to line their own pockets, with the enthusiastic support of the Pat Buchanans of this world.

Don't let Buchanan fool you. He doesn't give a shit about working class white men. He cares only about defending the privileges of the wealthy few against any gains by the working class and the poor.

Wake Up America! It is not about race, it is about wealth, the privilege of wealth and the maintenance of wealth! And I will resent it to my dying day.


Powered by FeedBurner

Saturday, May 30, 2009

"I was wrong about Sotomayor speech"

We have witnessed the barrage of attacks on Judge Sonia Sotomayor by the 'Right-Wing-Nuts' crowd (Sorry, this is the best composite word to describe people of that ilk)

It has become crystal clear that opposition to her nomination is not based on merits, but in destructive feelings of Racism, Xenophobia, Nativism, extremely intransigent Right Wing Ideology, et al.

To see and hear what these people are saying is so appalling and painful when compared to the reality of who Judge Sotomayor is, and what she has said and done, because it is so clear that her statements are being twisted, taken out of context and turned into completely false cartoonish (sic) portrayals of her.

The feelings of dismay surface when contemplating the desired prospect to engage in rational and civilized dialog / debate with people who have hate and intolerance as the core values in their positions, who are not interested, even in a small way, to disagree without being disagreeable, as it is supposed to be done in a Democracy as pertains to a civilized society; it makes you wonder if there is any hope for us to become what many people have dreamed, hoped for and voiced as 'A more perfect union'

Mancow Gets Waterboarded: Admits It's Torture - Mancow Muller of Chicago's Big 89, WLS-AM Mancow & Cassidy show, gets waterboarded to see what it's like and shares it with listeners and viewers. FULL STORY:

*WATERBOARDING 101* ~OLBERMANN

Who knows? But when I find nuggets of honesty in the Right Wing Camp, such as the honestly gritty Erich "Mancow" Muller's admission that 'waterboarding' is torture, he is paying the price for his reversal of opinion due to the 'waterboarding' stunt he performed trying to prove his position, it is being called a 'hoax' by people who refuse to admit the evidence, such as Sean Hannity who is stubbornly hanging to his beliefs on torture, despite his friend's assertion by personal experience to the contrary, who is also cowardly refusing to submit to a 'taste of waterboarding' as he said he'd do so to prove it isn't torture, in spite of people like Sean, I feel that there is a gleam of hope in the horizon because I firmly believe he is part of a minority, albeit malignant, I still take heart in the fact that it is a minority.

And, by the way, how is it that these people are disregarding testimony and statements of experts on interrogation techniques? These professionals have been saying all along that 'waterboarding' is torture, that 'waterboarding' is a misnomer, that it should be called 'drowining' as Mancow referred to it afer his experience, statement he repeated in two appearances on Keith Olbermann's COUNTDOWN - "Changing the Torture Debate" and in "Waterboarding Hoax?".

As I said before, this refusal to admit evidence by these kind of people is both appalling and painful if you believe in fairness and honesty, which people of that ilk obviously don't.

Following a link in a post titled On Racism in the Jim Wallis & Friends blog, God'sPolitics, I read a post by conservative blogger Rod Dreber where another nugget of Right Wing honesty can be found, where an example of how we absolutely must inform ourselves, to the best of our ability, on the facts of the matter in any given issue and have the courage to perform our civic duty to be an 'informed electorate', is displayed, that I decided to post it while applauding Rod's honesty and integrity on this issue.

Why applaud you may ask? After all, isn't that what we all are supposed to do? Well yeah, you are right but I can't help myself from rejoicing at the prospect that there may be more Rod Drebers and Mancows on both sides of the aisle out there.

Even while applauding Rod's finally reading the full speech , "A Latina Judge's Voice" By Sonia Sotomayor,
there are several questions that beg answers, since the full text of the speech was published on May 14th, why did Rod continue to perpetuate the distortions until the 27th? That's almost two weeks before he informed himself of the facts - and why is it that Tom Tancredo and Rush Limbaugh are still distorting and using Judge Sotomayor's words and using to pin degrading false labels on her?
The two possible answers go from the ugly to the horrifying, a) they refuse to fully inform themselves thus betraying their claims of Patriotism or, b) they have read her words and have put them aside in order to continue to be the 'horribly distorted beings' they appear to be on the surface.

Here is Rod's post:


Wednesday May 27, 2009
Categories: Law

The NYT has a link to the entire speech in which she made the comment about the "wise Latina" reaching a "better" verdict than "a white male who hasn't lived that life." I'm still a bit troubled by the remark, but not in any important way. Taken in context, the speech was about how the context in which we were raised affects how judges see the world, and that it's unrealistic to pretend otherwise. Yet -- and this is a key point -- she admits that as a jurist, one is obligated to strive for neutrality. It seems to me that Judge Sotomayor in this speech dwelled on the inescapability of social context in shaping the character of a jurist. That doesn't seem to me to be a controversial point, and I am relieved by this passage:

While recognizing the potential effect of individual experiences on perception, Judge Cedarbaum nevertheless believes that judges must transcend their personal sympathies and prejudices and aspire to achieve a greater degree of fairness and integrity based on the reason of law. Although I agree with and attempt to work toward Judge Cedarbaum's aspiration, I wonder whether achieving that goal is possible in all or even in most cases.

Relieved, because it strikes me as both idealistic and realistic. I am sure Sotomayor and I have very different views on the justice, or injustice, of affirmative action, and I'm quite sure that I won't much care for her rulings as a SCOTUS justice on issues that I care about. But seeing her controversial comment in its larger context makes it look a lot less provocative and troubling. As some of you have noted in comments.

UPDATE: In fact, come to think of it, I can remember a couple of occasions at The Dallas Morning News, sitting in on editorial board meetings with judicial candidates, in which I was favorably impressed by aspiring judges who talked about, well, empathy. One candidate who comes to mind had grown up poor and a racial minority, but had worked her way out of deprivation and built a strong legal career. She came to us as a sitting judge who sought higher office. We asked her to talk about a case or cases that would give us an idea of the perspective she would bring to the bench. She spoke about how she came to learn early in her bench career that the decisions she made affected not just the person at trial, but his family. She spoke about how it gave her a greater appreciation for the dimensions of the law, and what constitutes justice -- to be specific, that justice is not something mechanical, a result that can be obtained by feeding facts into a program, and having a computer spit out the "correct" answer. Rather, it requires wisdom, and its application. As I recall that meeting, the judge's answer struck me as wise about human nature, and how the law provides a framework for justice, but doesn't guarantee it -- and how sometimes, subjective factors necessarily influence a judge's decision about the right outcome in a particular case.

Also, I recall a black judge who came in for a candidate forum once. We put the same question to him. He talked about his hardscrabble background, and how he always tried to keep squarely in front of him when he had a black male defendant, "There but for the grace of God go I." His point was clearly not to assert that he had a different standard for black men who come into his court, but rather that his empathy (that word again) helped keep him humble in his approach to decision-making. If I remember correctly (this was a couple of years ago), I came out of that meeting thinking that I would feel pretty good about going before this judge's court as a defendant, because I could trust that judge to put himself imaginatively in my place, and try to see things as I did. That's not to say he would rule in my favor, but that he is at least aware that justice is not the same thing as rote application of the law; i.e., that while justice must never be entirely, or even mostly, subjective, it nevertheless requires taking into account particulars of the case. This is called wisdom. This is called judgment.


Powered by FeedBurner